Matthew Buxbaum is a web content writer and growth analyst for 1-800-D2C. If he's not at his desk researching the world of SEO, you can find him hiking a Colorado mountain.
Keeping customers coming back shouldn’t feel like a gamble. For any D2C brand selling consumables like skincare, pet food, vitamins, or coffee, repeat orders are the difference between a business built to last and one stuck chasing new customers who might not even convert.
Replenishment flows are the lever: purpose-built automations nudging buyers to restock before they run dry. But most brands’ attempts barely scratch the surface.
If your retention playbook starts and ends with a generic “it’s time to reorder” email, you’re leaving serious money on the table Let’s break down how modern D2C operators approach replenishment flows, including timing, triggers, messaging, and optimization, that actually stacks up to the best in the category.
[cta-btn title="Build Your Brand And Become A Member" link="/membership-pricing"]
D2C Dialogues: What Operators Say About Building Replenishment Flows for E-Commerce Brands
🧰 Must-Have Flows
“Your launch flows should always include welcome series, abandoned cart, browse abandonment, and post-purchase emails like thank-you and review requests.”
“Foundational flows for every store: site abandon, cart recovery, reactivation, and VIP follow-ups.”
💡 Smart Add-Ons
“Wishlist reminders, price drop alerts, and back-in-stock notifications can be incredibly effective if your catalog supports them.”
“If your product is consumable, don’t forget a replenishment flow—it keeps repeat orders coming in automatically.”
What Are Replenishment Flows and Why Do They Matter for D2C E-Commerce Businesses?
At their core, replenishment flows are automated email or SMS campaigns that proactively remind customers to reorder consumable products. The goal? Land a timely nudge in the window when supply is running low—not after it’s gone.
Done right, these flows consistently drive 60–70% conversion among existing customers (compare that to 13% for cold acquisition).
Why are they so effective?
Frictionless repeat buying: Remove “add to cart” decisions by meeting customers at the exact point of need
Substantial business impact: Increases customer lifetime value (CLV) and reduces churn
Makes loyalty habitual: Customers come to depend on you out of habit, not just price or novelty
If you sell anything people run out of, think trendy supplements or even coffee beans, and you aren’t running a replenishment strategy, you’re essentially letting additional, easy-orders go.
[single-inline-tool]
Setting Up Your First Replenishment Flow the Operator Way
You don’t need a team of engineers to get started if you’re using Klaviyo or Iterable. For Shopify or BigCommerce brands, the process is straightforward. In Klaviyo, you can set up a replenishment flow directly. In Iterable, the same is possible using Journeys triggered by Shopify purchase events:
Navigate to the Flows tab in Klaviyo (or Journeys in Iterable) and select “Create Flow.”
Select a replenishment template (Klaviyo) or build a custom sequence using a purchase-based trigger (e.g., “Placed Order” or event ingestion).
Add product-specific triggers: Only trigger flows for SKUs where repeat buying habits exist.
Filter out recent purchasers: Use profile filters or segmentation logic so you don’t annoy people who’ve already restocked.
Before you go live, test your trigger logic thoroughly. Don't hesitate to send previews, review conditional splits (first-time vs. multi-time buyers), and double-check that only target customers receive notifications.
Timing: The Real Money Maker in Replenishment Flows
Getting Timing Right In Replenishment Flows Is Worth Everything
Too soon, and you’re pestering. Too late, and the customer’s already bought elsewhere. Precision matters when turning replenishment flows into more orders. Here’s how operators get the timing right:
Calculate the “half-life” of each SKU: This means the average time it takes for 50% of buyers to need a refill.
First nudge: Send 3–5 days *before* that benchmark, catching customers when their stock is running low.
Follow-up cadence: If no reorder, send a reminder 3–5 days later, and a final email with a small incentive after the predicted depletion date.
Not every customer uses your product the same way. Survey buyers post-checkout (“How often will you use this?”), then segment into 20-, 30-, or 45-day flows. Let real usage through qualified A/B tests drive your timing and don't look to guess work.
Replenishment Messaging that Converts (Without the Spam)
Each touchpoint should feel personal, timely, and frictionless (not just another marketing blast). Winning emails and SMS campaigns have the following in common:
Subject lines that trigger urgency: “Running Low?” or “Almost Time to Restock?”
Dynamic product visuals: Show their purchase history and depleted-looking variants (think: GIFs of an empty bottle, progress bars).
Placement of CTAs in unexpected places: Embed “Replenish Now” buttons inside transactional emails like shipping confirmations—open rates here can top 80%.
Direct, non-repetitive copy: Skip the product features; focus on helping customers avoid running out.
Personalization: Reference frequency of use, previous flavors or variants, and even local delivery timing. For multi-regional brands, spotlight local shipping (“Ships from LA warehouse—arrives in 2 days”).
Advanced Replenishment Tactics for the Ambitious Operator
If the basics are in place, level up with tactics that D2C leaders use to push AOV and brand buzz stickiness even higher.
Five Battle-Tested Plays:
Micro-Bundles: In your replenish sequence, offer discounted “top-up” kits (main product plus travel size or a new flavor). This bumps AOV and introduces customers to more of your range.
Gamification: Reward streaks—offer badges, expedited shipping, or early access to new SKUs for customers who reorder two, three, or four times in a row.
Escalating Subscription Discounts: Instead of flat subscribe-and-save offers, increase the discount for each consecutive auto-replenishment—make canceling feel like leaving money on the table.
UGC and Emotional Proof: For supplements, beauty, or pets, showcase month-two customer results or progress photos in your replenish flow. Tie the act of repeat buying to tangible, visible success.
Channel Expansion: Pair email with SMS reminders (especially if the first nudge goes unopened) and retarget with inventory-specific ad creative (“Only 3 left in LA warehouse”).
Pitfalls Within Replenishment Flows and How To Avoid Them
Even the most successful brands make simple mistakes when setting up replenishment flows. From poor timing and vague messaging to sending reminders too frequently or not at all, these errors can cost you repeat sales. Here’s a breakdown of the most common pitfalls we see at 1-800-D2C:
Bad timing: Reminders sent too early (annoying) or too late (customer’s already churned).
Over-segmentation: Making flows so granular you lose operational clarity.
Zero personalization: Same cadence and copy for every customer, regardless of usage pattern.
Forgetting to filter: Sending reminders to customers who have already reordered is a classic rookie move.
Siloed channels: Overreliance on email without SMS or push for high-LTV buyers.
Not iterating: Skipping A/B tests for subject lines, incentives, or visual CTA placements leaves easy wins on the table.
Stand-Out D2C Examples: Who’s Getting It Right?
Chewy: Leverages urgency-driven copy (“Your pet’s food is running low—Autoship saves 10%”) injected into transactional flows. Result: High repeat rates and Autoship adoption.
Nuggs: Personalizes with quirky, on-brand reminders based on purchase cadence. The tone matches customer expectations and feels friendly, not robotic.
TeaTonic: Inserts wellness tips and bestsellers into replenish flows, converting email reminders into opportunities for add-ons and cross-sells.
Graza: Highlights local inventory in replenish comms, reducing cart abandonment thanks to delivery speed guarantees.
Riven: Creates FOMO with bulk purchase incentives and scarcity cues inside reorder nudges.
What’s consistent across these brands? A willingness to experiment even with failures and a dedicated focus on relevance and timing.
Measuring What Actually Matters
Set clear benchmarks for your replenishment flows by tracking measurable performance across key metrics. Monitor open and click-through rates, conversion rates, time to reorder, and overall impact on customer lifetime value. These insights help you identify what’s working, spot opportunities for improvement, and ensure your flows are driving consistent, measurable growth within your retention strategy.
Open and click-through rates: of each nudge
Repeat purchase rates: and time between orders
Revenue per recipient: (is the flow actually driving incremental sales?)
Overall CLV: compared to pre-flow launch
Unsubscribe and complaint rates: overcommunication is a real risk
Build a company D2C culture of continuous, thoughtful testing: A/B subject lines, CTA placements, email vs. SMS split, incentive size, and visual content. Let data, and not gut feelings, refine your approach.
The Next Phase: Integrate, Personalize, Innovate for Converting Flows
Replenishment flows are never “set and forget.” To keep them effective, regularly test new messaging, adjust timing based on usage data, personalize based on purchase behavior, and explore adding e-commerce incentives (think discount codes and loyalty rewards). Continuous iteration ensures your flows stay relevant, engaging, and aligned with how your customers actually shop, helping you maximize repeat revenue over time.
Loyalty program tie-ins: Give points for each reorder, redeemable next time
Polls and micro-surveys in post-purchase or replenish sequences: Use responses to personalize timing and offers
Predictive analytics: Let AI forecast when individual customers will run out and trigger reminders dynamically
Interactive content: Quick-action reorder buttons, mobile-optimized flows, and personalized landing pages embedded in emails
The brands dominating retention aren’t relying on hope. They obsess about when and how customers want to reorder and use replenishment flows as a cornerstone of their conversion strategy engine. If you’re not already thinking about what happens after the first conversion, start now. Your future brand operator will thank you.
[inline-cta title="Discover More With Our Resources" link="/resources"]
Frequently Asked Questions for Replenishment Flows
What Are Replenishment Flows And Why Do They Matter?
At their core, replenishment flows are automated email or SMS campaigns that proactively remind customers to reorder consumable products. Done right, these flows consistently drive 60–70% conversion among existing customers.
How Do You Set Up A Replenishment Flow?
Navigate to the Flows tab, select a replenishment template or create a custom sequence using the "Placed Order" trigger, add product-specific triggers, and filter out recent purchasers. Before going live, test your trigger logic and preview all customer paths.
What’s The Best Timing For Replenishment Reminders?
Calculate the "half-life" of each SKU, then send your first nudge 3–5 days before that benchmark. Follow up with reminders and incentives if no reorder occurs.
How Can You Personalize Replenishment Messaging?
Winning messages reference frequency of use, previous flavors or variants, and even local delivery timing. Embed CTAs in high-open emails and skip product features in favor of helping customers avoid running out.
Repeat's Smart Replenishment platform is designed to turn one-time buyers into repeat customers. Use the tool to analyze order data to determine baseline replenishment intervals that get smarter over time + Give customers a frictionless reordering experience with no account login required.
